Everton Banter Archive November 14 2017

14 Nov 2017 20:14:35
latest in the rags apparently we will go back in for the Silva increasing the fee and doubling his wages and a hefty Jan warchest.

14 Nov 2017 20:33:32
It reminds me of Southampton GB. They said Koeman couldn't go, then Koeman said he was interested and bang. We got him. Watch this space.

14 Nov 2017 20:44:22
you right there Smit mate, as I said earlier once a club goes in for a manager they usually get their man.

14 Nov 2017 20:56:37
And Silva Has said he'd be interested so it's probably just a matter of a big enough pay off to the Watford owners. And to be fair Watford would sack him in the summer if he doesn't get them higher than 8th.

14 Nov 2017 21:11:05
still not sure of him though mate, i think Dyche would have been my choice after Simeone.

14 Nov 2017 22:18:27
My only concern about Dyche is his erratic away form last season and his erratic home form this season.

14 Nov 2017 14:36:11
Number 1 has to be Simeone, don't care if it's unrealistic, don't ask you don't get. I didn't think Liverpool could get Klopp because he was desperate for the Bayern Munich job and wanted the Man Utd job but Liverpool got him. If not Simeone then Emery, then you keep going down the list, not up the list, start with the best and if you can't get the best then get the second best and if you can't get the second best you get the 3rd best and so on. Can't have a small club mentality.

{Ed001's Note - to point out you are incorrect, Klopp wanted the Liverpool job, rejected United and never wanted the Bayern job. He has said both publically and privately that it would be impossible for him to take the Bayern job as it would be a betrayal of Dortmund. Klopp always wanted the Liverpool job, I know people who grew up playing with him and doing coaching courses with him and he always wanted the LFC job even back when he was starting out.

As for Simeone, I am not sure it is that unrealistic. He is busy learning English, wants to manage in England and there are not many options open to him. Things in Madrid are not good at this time, he has hit a wall and can't really take them any further. I don't see why Everton couldn't get Simeone.}

14 Nov 2017 15:16:29
Very interesting comments about Simeone Ed001. If it is feasible I don't see it happening until next summer, in which case we would need a short-term appointment until then with someone like Unsworth or Allardyce. What do you think?
Mike.

{Ed001's Note - if that was the case, I agree, though I am not sure the club would be willing to wait due to the prospect of relegation. I really believe Simeone just needs the right club, somewhere that has ambition and the kind of togetherness that Everton has with its fans as well.}

14 Nov 2017 15:26:07
Thanks Ed001, let's hope it happens, it it does it will be exciting times.

{Ed001's Note - you are very welcome mate.}

14 Nov 2017 16:02:17
I agree go all out for compensation, read some where today that we were willing to pay 8.5m for someone that has not done anything yet, Dyche is a better bet and I think he has earned the right to a bigger job if you ask me the guy has got Burnley 19pts already and played some tough games already.

14 Nov 2017 16:51:09
Fair enough Ed I remember seeing something either he wanted the Bayern job to replace Guardiola or they wanted him to replace Guardiola, either way the point still stands that I didn’t think Liverpool could get him but they showed ambition and did and we need to show the same

You’re very right in regards to the feel of the club, he’d be loved here, I think it’s a great fit and not just because I want him as manager :)

You recently spoke about Emery’s issues with Neymar and I know another ed mentioned Silva in regards to his coaching and stuff, have you heard anything negative about Simeone such as his coaching, managing etc.

{Ed001's Note - only in terms of him being very intense, which requires the players to buy into it. The players do love him though, so it is not really a negative. Maybe some people would say his style of play was a negative, as it is not as technical as the Barcas or Real Madrids, but I don't think that is such a bad thing. To be honest, Simeone seems to be very well liked inside the club, worshipped even.}

14 Nov 2017 22:18:06
How can anyone pick Dyche over Simeone? Dyche is a good manager and I would have him before pretty much all the favourites at the moment.

But Simeone is world class. I worship him for the work he has done already. If he came to Everton it would be enormous. Imho he's better than Mourinho, Pep, Ancelotti or anyone. Well worth the £8.5m imho.

15 Nov 2017 11:04:33
Cheers ed

Would be brilliant to have him.

13 Nov 2017 23:53:45
So, simply put, how much are watford going to take, 2, 3, 5 mill?

14 Nov 2017 12:17:26
Maybe it’s a smokescreen? Unusual to be still rumours and the Echo not confirmed it, it all seems to be National as much as not everyone likes the echo they usually quick with such things and must have close connections. It’s just a gut instinct saying things will move pretty quickly now and it maybe another candidate.