Everton Banter Archive July 21 2015

 

Use our rumours form to send us everton transfer rumours.

21 Jul 2015 21:12:22
So the season is nearly upon us and regardless of the who signs who goes saga I am looking forward to the unpredictable visits to goodison. Last season felt like a chore going the game and maybe this season may be the same but I will always still find myself every home game sat in my seat hoping that the day will be a good day. This season is the season I am introducing my 2 year old daughter to her birth right, her religion her future so hopefully goodison will be bouncing a lot more than it was last season and we can come away happy. So fellow blues let's set the negativity aside and let's be positive and look forward rather than back and let's see what the season brings. Remember we are chosen we do not choose. But we can choose to get behind all our players that includes cleverly and kone as they wear that shirt that we were chosen to support. Born blue live blue die blue.

Believable3 Unbelievable4

21 Jul 2015 21:53:41
Great post mate coyb

Agree2 Disagree2

22 Jul 2015 19:20:58
Nice post blue why anyone would press disagree I'm not sure show you how sad some on here are

Agree0 Disagree0

21 Jul 2015 20:31:26
If stones goes and let's be honest chelski have got there claws in. Who could we replace him with? There are a couple of names we have been linked with in the past Ryan Shawcross, Curtis Davis, Ben Gibson don't get me wrong I don't want to lose Stones far from it just hope his head hasent been turned either way we still need back up to stones and jags feelings people we need cover Galloway is ok for cover as long as we keep stones thoughts?

Believable1 Unbelievable0

22 Jul 2015 00:54:29
If we sold stones and Martinez tried to get away with replacing him with one of those players I would be seething.

Agree0 Disagree1

22 Jul 2015 02:58:14
Av tried to explain without sucess why do poeple blame stones for goinbg were a team that dosnt competete although he'd get more games here the chances of wimming a thing are slim, we took him of a tean for buttons compared to rhe figures being banded about so why is irt suprising a team can do it to us

Agree0 Disagree0

22 Jul 2015 07:46:04
Mike

I don't think anyone would blame Stones if he went mate, he has not once pulled the Sterling Sulk, or been in the press for anything bad. I know if it was me and (I love Everton nearly as much as my kids) and someone offered me a job in the champions side with probably treble your wages, I would be skipping and singing all the way down to Chelsea, he hasn't asked for a leave or put transfer request in so top lad.

He has handled himself impeccably and if the right offer comes in like all football players he will follow the cash flow.

Agree2 Disagree0

21 Jul 2015 20:27:42
We get too attatched to our players at Everton. That was fine many years ago, as there wasnt o much money and size of clubs around. Now we are not one of those clubs, whenever we get a really top talent, we take them to our hearts then they are gone and we feel hard done bu, Jeffers, Rooney, Rodwell, Barkley and now Stones. Sadly its the way of the World of football, money dictates and there is nothing ya can do about it. We can plead the player shows loyalty, stay to learn and move later, once a blue always a blue, sorry its all bolox, because once the price is right that's it. More often than not to the detriment of the player as they can't get into the big clubs team, bench warm, confidence gone, a wasted 2 or 3 seasons and they move on half the player they were at Everton! Its life, football life TODAY!.

Believable3 Unbelievable0

21 Jul 2015 23:48:03
Yep perfect example is Rodwell bench warmer at city and now being warned at Sunderland to up his game, sad but very true.

Agree2 Disagree0

21 Jul 2015 18:53:17
At the end of the day money talks and if Chelsea offer over 30 mil then we know our board will take it that's bad enough but if that' money's not invested back into our squad we are up s**t creek I have a bad feeling if stones goes we are going to go in for Evans that's like replacing a Ferrari with a Morris minor I pray I'm wrong

Believable1 Unbelievable0

21 Jul 2015 18:46:15
McLaren's magpies seem 2 have made a couple of decent signings.
Fear not Martinez will try get us a few loanees & free transfers b4 window closes

Believable2 Unbelievable0

21 Jul 2015 17:05:38
does intrest remain in nolito ed and out the players we have been linked with who would u like to see come in

Believable1 Unbelievable0

{Ed025's Note - i think the nolito ship has sailed bretto, and i would like anyone half decent mate..

21 Jul 2015 15:52:50
Stones apparently wants the Chelski move.oh dear, this might be trouble brewing. that would explain Joses confidence, he's been tapped up I reckon! Knowing Bobby I guess he'll recall Alcatrash from Paraguay in the event of Johnny being sold.what a joke this all is!

Believable3 Unbelievable3

21 Jul 2015 18:33:47
who said he wants to move?

Agree0 Disagree0

21 Jul 2015 14:21:03
Right chaps this is what we have done in the last 5/6 years selling wise

Lescott - Dug our heels after citys original 16 million offer, dragged on through the summer (which didn't help us) but eventualy got 27 million for him

Rodwell - Footballer with plenty of talent but no product or drive, injury prone and apart from the odd glimpse struggled to get into our first team, we got 15 million for him

Baines - About 6 transfer windows in a row united wanted him. Derisory bids even a double one of 24 million for him and fellaini we laughed off. United ended up bidding more and we still said no

Fellaini - Along with previous bid with Baines got rejected sold a couple of weeks later for 27 million as well as getting him to place a transfer request (no money for fellaini). 27 million despite a month earlier had a buy out clause of 24 million

We even got good money for Anichebe & Jelavic

Still people think the board will crumble and sell Stones under what they value him at. If their is one thing the board are great at is getting money via transfers or even getting them to stay a little longer or staying completely.
If he goes it will be for silly money or he will stay, players have come and gone before john stones and it will happen again.

Believable4 Unbelievable0

21 Jul 2015 15:44:08
Great post HB

Agree2 Disagree0

21 Jul 2015 15:51:48
Totally agree , good post that mate

Agree2 Disagree0

21 Jul 2015 16:05:45
Honest Blue. Well put my son. Be ready for the negativity post to come but I'm fully with you on this.

Players have the power but if they want to stay we will keep them. Long gone are the days when players are sold because we need the money.

Plus we have 42 days of he transfer window still open. We are only 33% through the window so far. People need to be positive, who knows what will happen.

Agree2 Disagree1

21 Jul 2015 17:44:22
Good post

Agree1 Disagree0

21 Jul 2015 17:44:47
Paid 28 million for a player that Chelsea did not want and cost them 20 million. Any dealings we have with Levy for one always end up costing us. Stones will go for 26-28 million to Chelsea.

Agree0 Disagree1

21 Jul 2015 18:31:50
I'm willing to put my mortgage on it stones will b a Chelsea player soon enough irrespective of the price.Mourhino no fool & usually gets wot he wants

Agree1 Disagree0

21 Jul 2015 12:38:17
Its not a rumour but just curious on what peoples perception of Rooney playing in the Testimonial is? When he shows up with United he will get booed but surely this is a good thing and we should be a bit more friendly towards the lad? Yes Kissing the utd badge was a silly mistake but a young lad getting called a fat knobhead and he's having a bad game he's not going to be making the best decisions. I for one will give him a round of appplause and put the boo's and insults on hold until Utd come to Goodison

Believable4 Unbelievable2

21 Jul 2015 13:12:16
I admit I hated him for years but matured a bit now, I have no bad feelings towards the lad at all, we all know he is still a blue at heart

Agree3 Disagree1

21 Jul 2015 13:53:26
I'll cheer him for sure. If Dunc wants him there that's good enough for me.

Agree3 Disagree1

21 Jul 2015 15:10:18
Exactly my point of view!He hurt a lot of blues because he was seen as our Talisman who came through the ranks as a fan, but he left for the best team in the country and has gone on to win a lot of trophies he was never going to win if he stayed at Everton. and also his sale money helped stabilize us and without it would we have seen the likes of Cahill & Arteta at the club?

Agree1 Disagree0

21 Jul 2015 16:01:22
The more I saw of Moyes when he left the more I swayed towards Rooney. I was fully behind Moyes over the argument between the two until Moyes left. The when he came out in a press conference on Sky and said "if he was manager he would let Baines and Fellaini go to further their carears" I realised how ruthless and selfish he was as a person.

Moyes has no morals and no loyalty towards anyone. Even Kenwright who he treated with nothing but contempt through the whole process of him going to United.

Rooney for me, all is forgiven. I'll sing my bloody lungs out for him and Dunc.

Agree2 Disagree0

21 Jul 2015 20:43:18
I've no problem with Rooney playing, also it will give Kenwright the opportunity see if he wants to invest.

Agree0 Disagree0

22 Jul 2015 05:19:20
Tedster av heard it first hand he ain't playing for us contractually again after Man U he will go to America to earn a shed load again, why you think kenwrights part of the scouting team anyway I don't know, he's a good lad that went to someone who were winning a lot, if there's poeple who still hold a grudge need to have a hard look in mirror and realise there's more to life

Agree1 Disagree0

21 Jul 2015 12:29:30
Rooney to play in blue again, what is all the fuss about can't believe there are still some fans that don't forgive him for leaving, probably the best player produced since Gazza was in a team that were struggling on and off the field we were in financial problems at time where we had to sell best players, this not the case anymore, the boy was destin for the top, yea yea I know he had the famous once a blue always a blue, which is still the case he loves Everton his kid is always wearing blue and his best friends are evertonians but honestly he was never going to stay over 10 years on we are a different club take stones for example not saying we won't sell him but we have a choice now where we don't have to sell to balance the books but let's face it if they bid 30 40 million, it's more of a business deal

Believable3 Unbelievable0

22 Jul 2015 05:19:52
Well said

Agree0 Disagree0

21 Jul 2015 11:23:55
Is Pato becoming the new Riquelme?

Believable4 Unbelievable0

21 Jul 2015 10:55:27
Got to love the good old English press, they do their best to sell our top players and don't even get a percentage once they go.
Stones is definitely interested in Chelsea, according to one rags 'source' and the figure is between 26m and 34m. We have already sent a letter to Chelsea, explaining he is not for sale and we don't want to sell. This is what JM came out and said we had to do if we don't want to sell. Then they ignore it! I'd report them for trying to unsettle the player.
But. where is our cut off? How much would we actually decide to do business for? I'd ask for the same amount as LFC got for RS. Stones is under contract until 2019, he says he wants to stay at the club and, not only is he a home grown player, he is also one of the countries top prospects. These factors should be enough to bump up any bid. I think he should stay for at least another year, especially if he wants to go to the euro's this summer. If he has a good tournament then there will be other teams wanting to sign him so an auction will have to take place. Chelsea are trying to get him on the cheap now to avoid going head to head with other teams. Hope the board and manager hold firm on this

Believable4 Unbelievable0

21 Jul 2015 10:45:57
John stone, is one year, into a five year contract, thus, if Everton are as good as their word, there is no story. If someone where to come in with "crazy" money, say 50m + then maybe it would be something that they had to sit down and think about, but until or unless such an offer where to be put on the table, there is nothing to talk about.

Believable3 Unbelievable0

21 Jul 2015 13:57:43
And there endeth the lesson JCW

Agree1 Disagree0

21 Jul 2015 08:46:14
A previous poster mentioned Rio Ferdinand transfer from Leeds to Man U those years ago for around 30m. I put John Stones in the same situation. I hope he stays at EFC but in the event he confirms he wants to go then Ferdinands value of 30m has to be revalued say to 50m at today's values and that figure put on Stones. The Manager and Board have then to be strong enough to adopt the same attitude LFC did with Sterling and say 50m not a penny less.
The club should realise they have been ripped off by Chelsea in the past reference 28 m for Lukaku and shouldn't let it happen again. The saying 'once bitten twice shy ' comes to mind.
The club should be proud that they have a CB pairing that also fits in the England team and do their upmost to keep that in place.
Another striker is absolutely essential and the longer the club stall in getting one in then they will find the best targets have been snapped up by other clubs and will have to do with what's left.

Believable2 Unbelievable0

21 Jul 2015 09:49:48
In todays market of silly money, I agree if he goes its at the right price as Liverpool and spurs have recently done regardless of if a player is really worth it!

Agree0 Disagree0

21 Jul 2015 08:21:56
To reiterate my point the other day, why are the FA taking no action against Chelsea and their open pursuit of Stones, it smacks of the city and lescott debacle, make the bids public in an effort to unsettle the player who will then (usually with the help of his agent) angle for the move to happen.
Perhaps Mr's Abramovich and Mourinho just see RM & BK as weak men that will fold under the pressure. so unsurprisingly a tabloid today runs a story that 'sources close to Stones say he wants the move'!
unfortunately as we all know money makes this league go round!

Believable4 Unbelievable0

21 Jul 2015 07:26:44
So, I'm sat here bored and instead of continuing to rant at how bad Cleverley is, how irritating the fans of newly rich clubs have become or why Sterling runs like Velma from Scooby Doo I thought I would start a discussion. Who do people think will be the flop signing of the season, the worst signing so far, the best signing so far, the signing that will shock people the most and are you happy with our business? Here is mine:

Flop Signing-Firmino, why? I couldn't resist, he will imo just not really do anything, the new Lamela? Probably not that bad but will not be that good imo, mainly because most people have no idea who he is. If Miley Cyrus and Neymar had a baby it would look like Firmino.

Worst Signing-Cleverley, do I need to explain why?.

Best signing-Schweinsteiger, because it's Schweinsteiger and he's boss.

Signing that will shock people the most-Cleverley, he will shock the doubters with just how bad he is.

Am I happy with our business? HELL.NO.

Believable1 Unbelievable3

21 Jul 2015 08:27:20
Nice post from you Swan, you feeling ok kidder

I agree with Firminho, he would be my flop without a doubt, even his previous fans are shocked he got sold for that much

I have slated Cleverley as much as you but am a bit of a gambling man so my signing that will shock people most (in a good way) is Cleverley lol, ye never know I do get a decent win in every couple of years.

Agree1 Disagree0

21 Jul 2015 09:00:04
I think cleverley will surprise a few of us,I certainly hope so. Flop for me so far will be Delph, nowhere near good enough to challenge for the title, he's only been bought because he English,there's plenty better out there

Agree1 Disagree0

21 Jul 2015 11:11:12
Against the Gooners the other day even though as a whole we were poor he was by far the best passer of the ball that day, give him a chance I say.

Agree1 Disagree0

21 Jul 2015 12:58:44
I think Cleverley will have Swan eating his words and as Swan's words are mostly full of sh** it would be a tasty meal.
Wellzee

Agree2 Disagree1

21 Jul 2015 14:05:03
What a load of Guff. I have never seen such poor thought out predictions in all my life. Purely based on preference, not knowledge.

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed025's Note - i think it was just a bit of fun ace to take our minds off this stagnant window so far mate..

22 Jul 2015 02:26:04
Prefrence being swienstiger has won league tiltles and world cups and cleverlys a joke of football totally behind swan here, we have a player man u let go for free not a perception a reality

Agree0 Disagree0

21 Jul 2015 01:07:47
Much as I respect Leon Osman I found his comments about Everton not being concerned or worried about all the new signings Liverpool have made over the last few weeks rather disconcerting to say the least! The top six or so teams in the Premier League. which is where Everton aspire to be every season, but presently lack consistency. all have 3/4 strikers, at least 2 of them being top quality. Chelsea have Costa & Remy & they can perm others. Man City have Aguero, Dzeko & Bony, along with others. Arsenal have numerous choices as do Spurs and just at the moment Man United are probably a bit light up front, but will probably sign a striker very shortly. Ozzie says he isn't worried by the signings across the Park They now have 4 Top Class proven strikers to choose from.Sturridge (when fit), Danny Ings & also 2 top Belgian International Strikers in Origi & Benteke. What have we got?? We have Lukaku.oh and Kone! Naismith plays up front but is not an out and out striker, same as Mirallas. Everton need to sign a top class striker, to play up alongside Lukaku all the time in a 4-4-2 formation. not in place of Lukaku if he gets injured. Think we saw enough in the Asia Trophy against Arsenal to see just how far behind we are, Arsenal took us apart at will & they can put 2 strong teams out at the same time. The Management & Board are not showing enough ambition to convince the likes of Stones, McCarthy & possibly Coleman to stay at the Club. Those players are the future of Everton FC and they and the Fans need reassuring that we aren't just going to be a mid table, selling Club. Chelsea apparently are preparing to come back with a £34mill offer for John Stones. I would like to Thank Abramovich and the Sheik at Man City and the Glazers at Everton for completely ruining the game of football as I know it! I would like to see Mourinho & Pelligrini etc actually "BUILD" a team. not just be able to BUY all the best players from around the world and try to mould them together. Just think Howard Kendall, Bill Shankly, Brian Clough . how highly rated as Managers/Coaches would they be today? They actually built teams from nothing and moulded them into brilliant footballing sides. If Everton are not able to hang on to our decent players because of lack of any success, then Martinez is wasting his time trying to build a side. It seems the "Money Clubs" can just buy who they like because Contracts arenm't worth the paper they are written on.

Believable4 Unbelievable1

21 Jul 2015 06:32:39
Well said Gv. It seems like the board are quite happy to have a 1st team and no one to challenge it unless out of U21 team. The way teams around us are strengthening,we are going back to the early 90s and mid table to avoiding relegation. We should be vying for players like Yarmalenko, Shaquiri, Austin, and players like that. Not seeing who Everton don't want in there squad, or showing interest in a player, but getting pipped to the post by (no disrespect), Stoke,West Ham, Swansea, Aston Villa,and teams like that. Finger needs to be fully pulled out their backsides and spend some money.

Agree3 Disagree0

21 Jul 2015 07:11:13
I stopped reading when you called Sturridge, Ings, Origi And Benteke top class. How is Origi proven? Terrible in the French league and has done zilch for Belgium and has not played in the Prem before. Benteke is a slightly better version of Balotelli, same play style just a but better at heading the ball and he is always injured. Ings is not top class, not even good enough for a top 10 team imo. Injury prone, would not take a penalty when his team needed him to, not a very good footballer. Sturridge is another always injured and despite being ripped into the last time I said it, I still don't think he's good!. If they are top class then so is Lukaku, who is better than all of them, Naismith is probably better than Origi aswell. We do need another striker but those 4 top class? Pffft

Agree3 Disagree1

{Ed001's Note - I don't rate Benteke, I want to be clear on that, but he is absolutely nothing like Balotelli, have you ever even watched either play or are you too busy whining about how crap everyone is to watch anyone play football? Benteke starts ahead of Lukaku because he is better than him, though neither are top class, it is just Benteke doesn't have the touch of an elephant on a rampage when trying to control the ball. Where does this complete nonsense about Balotelli and Benteke being similar come from? Balotelli likes to play off a striker, as a deep lying striker, whereas Benteke is an old fashioned target man.}

21 Jul 2015 07:11:16
I know what you are saying mate and agree with most of it, let me ask you this question and answer truthfully.

If we were bought by a gazillionaire would you give a toss about our new manager bringing a team through the youth system or would you be happier with us bidding and buying the best talent out there.

I know what my answer would be and call me arrogant but I would not give a hoot what any other club or fan would think of us.

unfortunately we are not one of the lucky/super rich 5 clubs in this country which have either mega rich owners or a massive world wide fan base, we have to work for our living and pay average salaries (lol) of up to 80k per week, the days when we can match any of these are long gone

Agree1 Disagree0

21 Jul 2015 07:39:53
And Tom Cleverley started ahead of better players with England, what is your point?. Benteke doesn't have a touch of an Elephant on a rampage, but unless you hoof it to him, he is pretty useless, and he cannot go past anyone, oh and before anyone brings up the Heitinga match in 2012-13, its Johny Heitinga, Kone destroyed him, as did everyone else.

Agree3 Disagree3

{Ed001's Note - my point is that Cleverley started ahead of better players because he was a Man Utd player, not because he was any good. Benteke is at Villa but starts ahead of Lukaku because he is better. You have the least knowledge of football of anyone I have ever read on these sites. You just slag off everyone without a clue of what they actually do because you are so busy looking for things to whine about. You are like an old woman! Benteke can go past people, he should do it more, but it is impossible to know whether that is down to instructions he is given by the coach or his attitude. It is attitude that is Benteke's problem, he is a sulker, and will give up if things aren't going his way. I don't even know why I am bothering, you literally know nothing about football that is not negative, you will never see anything but the negatives because you are so negative. I notice that you are busy skirting the fact that you still have not explained how Balotelli and Benteke are similar players. Easier to totally miss the point of a reply when it goes over your head though isn't it?}

21 Jul 2015 12:44:26
As much as it hurts to say swan at least they have 4 strikers injury prone or not, we have 1 and a bit. Eds response about Lukaku is right his first touch is so bad his second is either a throw in or a header. That brings me onto the next part of his game that being he never wins a header. ever. benteke starts ahead of Lukaku because he is better simple as that and as I said as much as it pains to say it I do it because it's true. Origi you are totally right about swan he is awful against us twice he was poor and was also named in the worst 11 in france in a poll. Ballotelli is just a waste he has talent but just cba using it most of the time. I do think sometimes swan you just rant to get a response and to get peoples backs up rather than having a debate with structure and sense its just a rant of how bad everybody is.

Agree1 Disagree0

21 Jul 2015 12:55:34
Owned.

Agree1 Disagree1

21 Jul 2015 12:59:25
@GV, I agree with Osman to a point. I'm not really bothered who they are bringing in across the park, I'm more concerned with our business and who we may or may not sign. Sturridge is top class, despite what Swan says, but is rarely fit. Ings an Origi are good prospects at decent ages. I rate Benteke but, as ed01 pointed out, his attitude is suspect. Playing wise, I think he is better than people give him credit for. Almost a goal every game in a struggling Villa side isn't too shoddy. We do need to reinforce our forward line but something tells me RM will be happy to see Kone play more rather than spend cash.
@Swan, he's not as injury prone as you seem to think. He had a bad Achilles injury before the world cup and seems to have picked up a couple of niggling ones as he played catch up. Previous to this he played a lot of games for his previous clubs
@Ed001, hahaha certainly told Swan there!

Agree0 Disagree0

21 Jul 2015 19:01:00
Oh please another vomit inducing ed 'ownage'? Please, if I had said Kone was terrible, would you have bothered? No, as soon as it's Liverpool, like a fly on a turd. I actually would of done the Balotelli and Benteke thing but I was too busy wondering why you think Benteke is better just because he starts for Belgium. But when it is Cleverley it is because of the club he plays for. Also, only see the negatives? Yeah okay, perhaps you should actually read some posts, Deulofeu? Happy with that. See? I only needed one example, now you can deduce that I don't only see the negatives. I just saw some negatives in Liverpool strikers, at which point did I say none of them could do anything? Never, not once. You mention Balotelli playing off the striker but that's funny, whenever I have seen him for Italy, Liverpool or City, he had the ball played at his feet and he would lay it off or try to turn the defender. But hey maybe he played off the striker for Milan/Inter. It is the curse of the non editors on these sites. It's been mentioned by a few posters (shortly before a ban for expressing these concerns), if you say one thing an ed may find hilarious (in a bad way), BOOM! Inabit, amirite?. I think for the good of everyone I will stop posting on these sites as I have to admit, I find a lot of it most, taxing, most of the eds are biased as hell and a lot of people are too sensitive. Please ban my ip after this too so I cannot post anymore as I will be tempted to again. Cheers.

Swan.

Agree0 Disagree0

{Ed001's Note - why would I argue about Kone being terrible, when he is? You would be the turd that is for sure, you certainly vomit up enough turds for posts. When did I say Benteke was better because he starts for Belgium? Are you really such a complete arrogant tit that you can't read other people's posts before trying to reply? You just make up so many lies in your head about how you have seen these players a million times before you were born that you don't know the truth any more. I said he started because he was better, not that he was better because he started, I take it that is too difficult a concept for you? As for Cleverley, you know full well I am right but you are such a knob that you will argue a point just because you won't admit to being wrong, which you normally are. You call other people too sensitive but then it is you that always bitches at them when they disagree with you. You need to grow up and have some respect for other views. You have clearly never even seen Balotelli play, your description of him is the least insightful analysis I have ever read, and that takes some doing. You might want to go back and actually watch him, you were obviously too busy making up lies rather than watching him, as usual with you. The only curse is us having to deal with you.}

21 Jul 2015 22:07:08
Well what did Golden Vision start here? hahaha quite entertaining. Swan will be back though, he's left his dummy on the floor yet again.

Agree0 Disagree0

 
Change Consent