Everton banter 46506


Use our rumours form to send us everton transfer rumours.

(single word yields best result)

01 Oct 2019 21:16:20
Ed, can we have a poll please? If so, I'd like to see which of the following three young players you think will do better in the first team
A) Anthony Gordon
B) Moise Kean
C) Ellis Simms


{Ed033's Note -

Young Players poll

Agree0 Disagree0

01 Oct 2019 21:25:12
thanks ed033.

{Ed033's Note - ok

01 Oct 2019 22:29:06
Proves nothing.

01 Oct 2019 22:35:21
Depends on the next manager.

01 Oct 2019 23:32:43
Uran, it proves that 75% of those who have voted think Kean would fare better than the other two.
DC, I could have worded it better sorry. It means right now, which of the three would do better.

02 Oct 2019 00:11:11
Then don't participate.
I often wonder what you get out of this site.

02 Oct 2019 08:24:42
It not your site! its a site for all to express their views on how the see the current situation and what they expect for the future
The Poll was put up to try and ridicule my my post over my opinion that Gordon, Simms should shortly be promoted to the first team match day Quad and then given the chance in the first team and that in my opinion that I would prefer Simms and Gordon to Our new 30m 19 year old signing from Juventus and 30m 22 year old Iwobi from Arsenal
That is only my opinion but others have to take it further to try and prove my opinion wrong, running a Poll for my benefit is a was of time and undermines this group of supporters and The young players of Everton FC.

02 Oct 2019 09:22:52
Don't know how anyone can prove an opinion wrong on this site as know one has any influence on who Silva plays where or when. Uran you're entitled to you opinion people can either agree or disagree. I picked Kean because I think he has more chance to do better, we don't even know if either Simms or Gordon will actually get a chance in the 1st team. Didn't have anything to do with proving anyone wrong just took part in the poll. Kean may well be a flop but I think once he settles in and gets a few goals he may do very well for us. I also think Iwobi has good potential and may also be a very good player for us. At the time of his signing I hadn't seen much of him so was quite surprised. Thought it was a bit of a strange one.

02 Oct 2019 09:29:09
The Poll is just a bit of fun imo Uran mate, keep your opinions coming though as it's always good to see what other Evertonians are thinking .
As for the poll I haven't bothered with it as I'll just stick with my 'Super 6' predictions at least I can study some sort of current form.

02 Oct 2019 09:35:54
Thank you sa90 for your reply to my post and your comments and I can see clearly why you voted for Kean and not the others I have no problem with this it’s your view.

02 Oct 2019 10:46:09
Blue247 Thank you.

02 Oct 2019 11:31:19
Uran, why do you think this is to ridicule you? I requested a poll to see what other people on here thought of what we were both saying, that's what the poll tab is there for isn't it? I've got better things to do with my time than 'ridicule' people over the internet so I wouldn't be so paranoid.
I said it the other night and you have mentioned it again yourself above, there is no right or wrong it's all about personal perception, we all have our own opinions.
The funny thing is, Uran, that I was in agreement over the use of young players, I'd like to see more of them get into squads throughout the league. But managers won't do it unless they are forced into it through injuries etc. But, unlike what you suggested, Gordon will not be sold for the same price or more as Kean, not unless he gets a lot of first team games under his belt!
Again, don't take it personally, I just wanted to gauge the thoughts of others on here. Have a nice day.

02 Oct 2019 13:42:38
Well i didn't make the connection with your comment so i thought you were ridiculing it.

02 Oct 2019 13:52:16
Actually I don't think any of them are ready. I have seen nothing from Kean so far that would suggest he is ready for premier football. I would like to see Gordon given a chance just because of his versatility, but it will not happen soon just because we are desperate for points and Silva is not going to risk kids.

02 Oct 2019 14:07:56
BlueMike, the final part of your comment above is the exact point I was trying to make to Uran. You may be correct in saying that Kean isn't exactly ready, it can take a while for some foreign players to get up to speed with the league. That said, due to the experiences he's had with Juve, I think he is better prepared than the other two.

03 Oct 2019 19:57:30
No Problem Blue potato, take care.



Log In or Register to post

Remember me

Forgot Pass